The Best Unicorn Recipes You Can Actually Make at Home

These are the best unicorn recipes floating around on the Internet that you can actually make! From milkshakes and marshmallows to truffles and toffee, add a little magic to your day.

RELATED READING: Printable Unicorn Mask for a Unicorn or Magical Party

Here at Ruffles and Rain Boots, we’re setting up a unicorn birthday party and of course, I had to gather up some great recipe ideas. Everything on this list isn’t exactly considered health food but it’s magical.

The Best Unicorn Popcorn

We’re HUGE fans of gourmet popcorn around here (Samoa Cookie popcorn, Tangled Up In Purple popcorn) so the unicorn popcorn recipes are calling our name!

The Best Unicorn Popcorn Recipe – Our colorful concoction has been featured in magazines because it’s that good (and it looks amazing).

Unicorn Popcorn – Life Love Liz made this pastel perfection.

Rainbow Unicorn Popcorn – If you have a lot of time and want to go a bit overboard, check out this one from A Decorated Cookie.

The Best Unicorn Recipes – Drinks

True story: I split the tall (ahem, small) Starbucks Unicorn Frappuccino with 4 people and it was so over-the-top my mouth still puckers when I think about it. But it was so sparkly and magical it was almost worth it.

Easy and Natural Unicorn Milkshake – We created a fun, easy, and natural milkshake that looks like a ton of fun.

Unicorn Hot Cocoa Bomb – If you’re setting up a winter get-together, these are the world’s best cold-weather dessert. And they make a jaw-dropping party favor.

Grown-Up Unicorn Frappuccino – Sandy a la Mode featured her friend Jennifer’s “absolute perfection” take on that big coffee chain’s colorful cup-o-magic.

Magical Unicorn Milkshakes – Cutefetti is the GODDESS of fun foods!

Unicorn Cupcake Recipes

Below are two mini cakes and they couldn’t be more different. Take a look to see if you want over the top (of the rainbow) or easy, peasy, sprinkles-easy.

Bakery-Worthy Unicorn Cupcakes – This decorating idea is going to wow the sparkly pants off of everyone!

Surprise Unicorn Cupcakes – Sometimes you need EASY and this cupcake recipe is that in spades.

The Best Unicorn Cookies and Treats

Everything on this list is a treat but makes for a WONDERFUL addition to a unicorn birthday party theme. Except the poop…

Unicorn S’Mores Recipe – Featured by a fun-loving, fashions-forward magazine, these s’mores are insanely over the top and will be talked about FOR YEARS (ask me how I know)!

Circus Animal Cookie Fudge – We whipped up a colorful fudge that is ridiculously easy to make. Everyone loves fudge…

Easy Unicorn Meringue Cookies – If you love meringues, you can get very easy cookies done in no time with some basic coloring. They look so magical!

Unicorn Muddy Buddy Recipe – No one will turn down at least a handful of my unicorn puppy chow / Chex Mix®. It’s so colorful and is great when wrapped in a cello bag for a party favor.

Easy Unicorn Marshmallow Pops – I love easy recipes and even ones the kids can help make because party prep is no joke. These fit the bill, just change the sprinkles to some unicorn themed sprinkles.

Unicorn Candy Horns Recipe – The kids are going to have THE BEST TIME making these unicorn horns.

Next- Level Unicorn Marshmallow Pops – The Decorated Cookie takes cake pops to the next level.

Unicorn Toffee – Tornadough Alli combines color with crunch in this fun toffee recipe.

No-Bake Rainbow Unicorn Cheesecake Bars – For more refined palettes, whip up this decadent dessert by Jocelyn from BruCrew Life.

Unicorn Pretzel Sticks – Sheryl from Lady Behind the Curtain turned an easy party favor into an easy and impressive party favor.

The Best Unicorn Breakfast Recipes

Yes, I made it a category of interest because waffles, parfaits, and donuts are breakfast foods. But that bread… I had no idea where to put that, other than in my tummy!

Unicorn Toast Recipe – Another one featured by a major magazine, this easy toast is a snap to put together and ‘takes the cake’ for a birthday girl.

Unicorn Rice Krispies Treats Recipe – Hear me out… it’s made of cereal, so that makes it okay for breakfast, right?

Unicorn Food Oreo Cookie Parfait – A Worthey Read made these and, while I don’t think they’re exactly breakfast food, they would be an amazing surprise birthday breakfast.

Lemon Raspberry Unicorn Donuts – Imma Eat That just elevated the donut game, friends.

The Best Unicorn Ice Cream

Mmmm, ice cream. Unicorn ice cream just takes things to a whole, new, magical level.

Unicorn Ice Cream Cones – Cutefetti is the queen of magical foods and this easy one doesn’t disappoint.

Unicorn Rainbow Ice Pops – All you need is a mold and this unicorn pops recipe from Flour on My Face

Low-Calorie Unicorn Sundaes – Cutefetti made a healthy-ish sundae for us!!!

More Unicorn Fun You Might Like

• Unicorn Craft Ideas and Printables – Setting up a party is hard work and these make it easier.
• Unicorn Rock Painting Tutorial – This is a popular project for unicorn parties and rainy afternoons.
• Unicorn Party Printable – Unicorn feed can be anything: our muddy buddy recipe above, fudge, candies – the sky is the limit and this free unicorn printable makes it easy.
• Easy Unicorn Party Favor Bags – Don’t worry, the kids can make these themselves.

Over to You

This list is over the top, yes, but you can’t go wrong with the best unicorn recipes on the ‘net when adding a little magic to someone’s day. What’s the one thing on this list for which you might be willing to risk a sugar coma? For me, it’s still the popcorn.

Please pin this – and share the unicorn love – to your favorite unicorn board on Pinterest. We grow with your shares and sincerely appreciate them.